When I recently moved guild I moved up a fair number of steps in the "boss kill" hierarchy, moving from 1/5 in Mount Hyjal, and 0/9 in Black Temple to regularly farming 4/5 and 4/9 respectively, with the kill on Gurtogg Bloodboil a week after I joined (and I participated as one of the three tanks), yet I didn't feel boosted through the content, I tanked a large proportion of it in that week and put out similar threat and avoidance to the other tanks, my shortcut sped up my progress through the game, but was at the gear and experience level I had. The question is though, if I had applied to a guild that had finished Black Temple, and was looking to gear up a tank for the Sunwell Plateau would I have felt boosted, and would this really be a bad thing.

In our guild we have a new recruit (well a week newer than I am), and he has no real 25 man raiding experience, but a lot of Karazhan experience. He worries that he won't perform and won't pull his weight in these instances, yet this never worried me for him, he knows his class, performs well and already has a high proportion of his potential damage at his gear level, in short the only thing he is lacking is having seen the bosses and played with 24 other people at once. Key to my not worrying though is that in a 25 man instance each person generally pulls less weight than in a 10 man instance, ok there are exceptions, Teron Gorefiend (1 person failing can wipe the raid with constructs), Archimonde (Dying causes massive damage to everyone else), Brutallus (29,000 raid dps please, not easy on progression), but in general you are focused on your part of the raid, your small section and your movement, the rest of the raid kindof just does its thing and provided each part does it it comes off. Taking the Shade of Akama as an example there are 2 tank groups whose sole job for the first part of the fight is to hold adds and ideally kill them while the other group takes down the channelers, in the second part the tanks and healers have to survive for 60s while the dps nuke the boss (threat free fight). I haven't really seen this fight, I stand to the side and try not to die as my adds pile up, the main body of the work doesn't concern me provided my 3-6 man group can keep me standing for the duration and I don't let anything through.

In contrast in 10 man instances everyone counts, you will often have fewer healers per tank, fewer dps, and a lot less synergy, you can't afford to slack and let people relax because there is no backup, any death can really push the group, a tuned pull such as in Zul'aman requires you to have your CC up, or be capable of dealing with massive burst damage. Your environment is closer and the challenges different, you work as one small group, or several micro-groups, in effect fulfilling one or two parts of what a 25 man raid is capable of, but doing so all the time, there isn't a "trash-slack" part where healer mana isn't an issue, nor is there a general tank-slack, I can't afford to simply expect one of the other tanks to pick up a broken enemy if I am AoEing, nor can I expect a feral kitty to pop tank and pull it back for us, the resources are a lot more finite and the awareness has to be higher. So our guy with no experience is doing the same, he is watching out for others, preparing to trap, watching dps and threat, in a 25 man I wouldn't really expect his to trap at all, in general zerging or Mages handles it, or there are spare tanks to deal with issues, he does more and has to be willing to do more in a 10 man instance than in a 25 man.

As a side note I was right, he came into Gruul and Magtheridon, ok with an experience and overpowered group, but that doesn't help him, got a few terse explanations and performed well, his knowledge and movement were fine, because he applied the experience he had from previous raiding levels, he kept his head and wasn't worried about the big picture, he did his job, and thats all you can ask and expect from a raider, because in any level of raiding we can cover some slack, but fundamentally its a 10 or 25 man instance for a reason.

So whats the point, really I don't know if jumping content is a good thing, but with a sufficiently aware player I don't think its a bad thing, you don't learn a lot more dodging Leotheras's whirlwind than you did on Hydross the Unstable, the aggro wipe mechanic is the same. You need to know a certain amount and have the skills to progress, but when you have them you only miss out on the learning portion of a boss, the sweet first kill, in fact there is probably no such thing in the end game as being "boosted", because everyone needs to actually fulfil their part. Your individual weight and contributions might be lower, and your death might not be a wipe, but it sure won't let your raid complete the kill easily, requiring on the fly group changes or massive overhealing and dps pushing the envelope to do it. In the end, hit the ground running, because the treadmill doesn't stop.

2 comments:

Larísa said...

I think jumping content isn't such a big problem as long as you don't jump around between different guilds too much. I think one of the things about raiding that I love most is that you share a history, that you're walking the same path for a while, that you get collective memories from endless wiping until you finally learn the fight and are able to take down the boss and move on.

Without the struggles the victories wouldn't taste as sweet at all.

If you make a raiding career without experience that side of the game you miss a lot.

thuân ngoc said...

Con trai thích con gái ở những điểm nào ?Để giúp các bạn gái hiểu rõ vấn đề cũng như giải đáp thắc mắc này mình xin chia sẻ một số kinh nghiệm sau đây.
Con trai lạnh lùng thích con gái như thế nào?Bạn đang để ý một chàng trai, nhưng anh ấy lại là một người con trai lạnh lùng, ít nói và ít đùa giỡn với mọi người.
Những thực phẩm tốt cho bà bầu 3 tháng đầuChú ý không nên lơ là cung cấp dinh dưỡng khi mang thai sẽ ảnh hưởng không tốt đến cả mẹ lẫn con.
Chế độ dinh dưỡng cho bà bầu 3 tháng đầuSớm biết được tin vui, có lẻ không ai hạnh phúc bằng mẹ bầu, mang thai là thời gian khó khăn nhưng chính thiên thần sắp chào đời kia chính là niềm vui của gia đình, giúp mái ấm thêm hạnh phúc hơn.
Đặt tên cho con trai – con gái hayThiên thần của bạn sắp được chào đời, nhưng bạn chưa biết phải đặt tên cho thiên thần của mình tên gì thật hay, thật ý nghĩa.
Đặt tên cho con trai – con gái theo phong thuỷPhong thủy là học thuyết chuyên nghiên cứu sự ảnh hưởng của hướng gió, hướng khí, mạch nước đến đời sống hoạ phúc của con người.
Đặt tên cho con trai – con gái năm 2015Cái tên cha mẹ đặt cho con nuôi bao hoài bão, ước mơ cha mẹ gửi gắm. Qua cái tên, cha mẹ cầu mong con có một cuộc sống an lành, tốt đẹp.
Bà bầu uống nước cam nhiều có tốt không?Nước cam chắc không còn gì xa lạ với mọi người rồi nữa nhỉ, được biết đến là nước uống giàu dinh dưỡng, vitamin các loại, rất tốt cho sức khỏe
Bà bầu bị cảm cúm nên làm gì?Còn virus cúm nói chung, các tài liệu khẳng định, khi người mẹ bị nhiễm cúm nặng thì tình trạng sốt cao, nhiễm khuẩn và nhiễm độc do virus gây ra có thể làm cho thai bị lưu và gây sảy thai
Bà bầu tháng thứ 4 nên ăn gì?Đối với người chồng khi vợ có bầu cũng có nhiều thay đổi trong tâm lý. Có người cảm thấy vợ trở nên quyến rũ hơn khi ngực và cơ thể đầy đặn hơn, cộng thêm niềm hạnh phúc khi có con mà vợ mang lại có thể thấy ham muốn sẽ tăng lên.
Bà bầu quan hệ nhiều có sao không?Quan hệ là chuyện giường chiếu của các cặp vợ chồng, nhưng khi các chị em mang bầu, thời gian này bà bầu khó khăn hơn trong việc quan hệ.